I asked Nashville visitors to weigh in on five popular downtown hotels, and the responses were overwhelming. People who've actually stayed at these properties shared honest feedback about what worked and what didn't.

The Drury
This one dominated the conversation. People love the Drury for reasons that go way beyond a clean room.
The breakfast is included, but here's the real draw — they also serve dinner and appetizers. And get this: three free alcoholic drinks per person every night. For anyone keeping track of vacation spending, that's a game-changer.
The pool area got mentioned repeatedly. There's both indoor and outdoor sections, plus a large hot tub. One visitor mentioned an outdoor hot tub specifically, which sounds pretty great after a day of walking Broadway.
Location-wise, it's walking distance to everything downtown. And the staff? Multiple people said they felt welcomed the moment they arrived.
<– CHECK PRICES & AVAILABILITY –>

The Cambria
This hotel came in as a strong second choice. The word “beautiful” came up a lot in these comments.
It's close to Broadway but far enough that you can actually sleep when you're ready. The rooftop patio and pool area impressed quite a few people.
Several visitors praised the staff for being friendly and helpful. The hotel itself is clean and well-maintained. One person did mention there's a bit of a hill walking back late at night, but most said it wasn't bad at all.
The location puts you near both Broadway and The Gulch, which gives you options.
<– CHECK PRICES & AVAILABILITY –>

The Bobby
This hotel has something the others don't — balconies. Apparently that's pretty rare downtown.
The rooftop bar and pool situation is a major selling point. You're right next to Printer's Alley, which puts you in the arts district rather than smack in the middle of all the Broadway chaos.
People described it as unique compared to the more corporate-feeling chain hotels. The styling got multiple mentions. It's close enough to Broadway that you can walk, but far enough that the noise doesn't keep you up.
<– CHECK PRICES & AVAILABILITY –>

Holiday Inn Express
A few people mentioned the Holiday Inn Express on Broadway. The reception with live music from 4-7pm is included, along with a hot breakfast buffet.
The beds are comfortable, the staff is friendly, and it's in a good location. One visitor noted it's an easy walk to both The Gulch and Broadway — about four blocks to lower Broadway specifically.
The rooms are big and the place is clean. For people who are mainly using the hotel to sleep and shower between activities, it's a solid choice.