I asked Nashville visitors which bars first-timers absolutely need to visit. The responses reveal a clear hierarchy of what matters when you're experiencing Broadway for the first time.

The Non-Negotiables
Tootsie's tops nearly every list, and there's a reason it's called iconic. But here's what most first-timers don't know: walk to the back and take the stairs on the left. There's an entire second bar and band upstairs. The third floor is worth the climb too.
Robert's Western World gets mentioned more than almost anywhere else. Order the recession special – a PBR, fried bologna sandwich, bag of Lay's chips, and a Moon Pie for $6. It's old school Nashville at its finest, and the music matches the vibe.

The Worst Times to Visit Nashville: Avoid These Dates
Read more →
Nashville’s 10 Most Jaw-Dropping Hotel Pools – #3 Will Leave You Speechless!
Read more →The Celebrity Spots
Kid Rock's bar generates strong opinions, but it consistently makes the must-visit list. The rooftop is the move, especially after 10pm when things really get going.
Redneck Riviera, Jason Aldean's, and Luke Bryan's Friends in Low Places all get recommendations. The chicken tenders at Friends in Low Places have their own fan base, particularly that ranch dressing.
Ole Red (Blake Shelton's place) offers solid entertainment, while Morgan Wallen's newer spot is drawing crowds who want to check out the latest addition to Broadway.

The Authentic Experience
Layla's appears repeatedly as a must-visit. It's where you'll find real country musicians without the celebrity branding overlay.
Legends Corner gets called out as a traditional bar worth your time. Ask for Amanda when you visit.
Music City Bar and Grill is the place some people don't want you to know about, which usually means it's worth knowing about.

Beyond Broadway
Whiskey Bent Saloon earned multiple shoutouts, particularly for Sunday afternoons. It's a favorite that doesn't always make the tourist guides.
Wild Beaver Saloon takes you off the beaten path for karaoke, bull riding, and $5 beers. Sometimes the best Nashville experience is the one you didn't plan.
Santa's Pub gets mentioned by people who want first-timers to see something completely different. It's about as far from Broadway as you can get while still being in Nashville.
The Strategy
One visitor put it perfectly: use your ears. If you like what you hear from the street, walk in and have a drink. If they still sound good, tip $1-5 or request a song. You might spend your entire night on one block and never feel like you missed anything.
Another pointed out what's obvious once you think about it: most celebrity bars are essentially the same. Just pick your favorite artist's name and walk in. The real differences show up in places like Robert's, where the vibe is less polished and more authentic.
The Practical Stuff
Not all bars charge cover charges, though it's a common question. Watch your drinks, your wallet, and your phone – standard advice for any major city's bar scene, but worth repeating.
For traditionalists, stick with Tootsie's, Robert's, Nudie's, and the newly opened Ernest Tubb's. These bars dial in Nashville's roots better than anywhere else.
The talent level across Broadway is consistently high. You can't really go wrong with live music in Nashville, which is part of the problem – there are too many good options. Start with the classics, follow your ears, and save the deep dives for your second trip.